The Grid Report

The Grid Report

Getting Likes Is Easy—Here’s How to Turn Them Into Sales

If you’re getting engagement but not conversions, here’s what to fix.

Apr 21, 2025
∙ Paid
2
Share

We’ve all been there—your post gets solid engagement. The likes roll in. Comments trickle down. Maybe someone even DMs you a “🔥.” But… no sales.

That disconnect? It’s usually not a content problem—it’s a conversion friction problem. Meaning: you’ve got their attention, but the next step (buying, booking, or even clicking) feels unclear or too effort-heavy.

Good news: You don’t need to overhaul your content strategy. You just need to smooth out the path between engagement and purchase. Here’s how to do it—step-by-step.


The Grid Report is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


✅ 10 Ways to Turn Social Engagement Into Sales


1. Use DMs as a Sales Tool

Stop thinking of DMs as the after-party. They're the main event.
Encourage followers to DM you for exclusive offers, links, or personalized recs. Example: “DM me the word GLOW for 10% off.”
This not only drives action—it boosts your engagement score in the algorithm.


2. Add Quick-Click Links Everywhere

Your audience is lazy (it’s not personal—it’s the internet).
Make sure your link-in-bio goes exactly where it should—a product page, booking page, or direct offer. Not your homepage. Not a dead end.
Tools like Linktree, Later, Stan Store, or Milkshake can help you organize clickable destinations.


3. Showcase Pricing Upfront

Don’t play hide and seek with your price.
Include pricing in your Reels, Stories, or captions—or at least pin it in a comment. If people don’t know what it costs, they’ll bounce.
Transparency = trust = conversions.


4. Make Story Highlights Your Mini-Website

Your Instagram Highlights should answer your audience’s FAQs before they ask.
✅ Bestsellers
✅ How to book/order
✅ Shipping & returns
✅ Customer reviews
✅ Before & afters

This reduces DM overload and gives buyers everything they need to feel confident.


5. Add “Comment to Buy” or “DM to Get the Link” Prompts

This works especially well for products, workshops, or limited offers.
Ask people to comment a specific emoji or word to trigger a DM reply or to send the link. It feels personal and boosts visibility. Here’s a post we did last year that’s ALL about Manychat (the service that lets you do this!)


6. Build Product or Service Walkthroughs

People convert when they feel like they understand what they’re buying.
Use Reels or Carousels to walk your audience through:

  • What’s included

  • How it works

  • What problem it solves

  • What the transformation looks like


7. Use Clear CTAs in Your Captions (and Audio!)

Don’t just end with “Let me know what you think.”
Instead:

  • “Click the link in bio to book.”

  • “DM me DETAILS and I’ll send you everything.”

  • “Save this post to shop later—limited stock!”

  • “Tag someone who needs this!”

Make your CTA clear and easy.


8. Use Pinned Comments to Reinforce the CTA

If your caption is long or if the Reel is getting lots of traction, pin a comment with the most important info:
✅ Product name
✅ Price
✅ Where to buy
✅ Bonus/discount/urgency
This keeps your sales CTA top of feed.


9. Test Reminder Stickers on Stories

Instagram’s Reminder Sticker lets you alert followers before a launch, drop, or event.
It lives on their lock screen if they opt in.
Perfect for:

  • New product drops

  • Workshop openings

  • Limited-time offers


10. Create a “Link Hub” in Captions

Sometimes you want to feature more than one offer or product in a single post. Use a link shortener or Shopify collection and drop it in the caption:
“Everything I mentioned here is linked at [short link].”
Keep it clean and easy to remember (because remember - captions can’t be clicked!)


💡 Bonus Tip: Make the Process Look Easy

The less mental effort it takes to buy from you, the more likely they’ll do it.
Show people how fast your checkout process is. Show how easy your service is to use. Let them see how frictionless it really is.


The Bottom Line?

Getting engagement is great.
Turning that attention into action is the goal.
So before you post your next Reel, ask:
👉 Is the next step obvious?
👉 Is it easy to take?
👉 Does it feel like a no-brainer?

If not—use the list above to tighten it up.


THIS WEEK: backup plans, team chaos, and our shared delusions.

This week’s trending Reels bring vulnerability, chaos, and humor—aka the stuff that actually gets people to stop scrolling. From showing how Plan A flopped (but Plan B was better), to calling out who really runs the show behind the scenes, these trends are easy to jump on and deeply relatable. Let’s get into it 👇

HOP ON THESE TRENDS: Three Trending Reels (and How to Use Them)

These Instagram Reel trends are hot right now (late April 2025). For each trend, we explain what it is, how to shoot it, ideas for on-screen text, and the trending audio you’ll need. Steal these for your brand or niche and give them your own twist:

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Grid Report to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Alison Piepmeyer
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture